Letter to the Editor: The Earned Income Tax is Not the Answer

November 19, 2026
Phoenix Photo/Avery Bloom

Editor’s Note: This letter was prior to the passage of the Earned Income Tax of 1% by The Swarthmore Borough Council.

Like Jack Nicholson in “The Shining,” the Earned Income Tax (EIT) is hard to kill. Last year, it was proposed to help close the gap created by the need to fund Emergency Services in the aftermath of the bankruptcy of Crozier Hospital. With the help of a large donation by Swarthmore College, it was defeated. This year, it is being proposed as a permanent new source of revenue. 

First, contrary to what has been said publicly, the Borough does not need a new revenue source. It can continue to fund its needs, as it always has, by the property tax. Borough Council simply needs to raise the millage, as it has done many times in the past. The problem with the property tax is that it is regressive: as income increases, individuals pay a smaller percentage of their income in property taxes because the assessed value of their homes does not rise proportionally with their income. But, as I wrote in The Swarthmorean last year, the EIT is also a regressive tax, and as applied, it is very likely to be more regressive than the property tax.

The EIT is regressive in principle because it excludes all unearned income — this includes all capital income (stocks, bonds, mutual funds, distributions from retirement plans, income from the ownership of property, etc.). Unearned income is very heavily skewed to higher income individuals, much more so than the lack of proportionality in property tax assessments mentioned above. The EIT taxes the earned income of everyone who works in Swarthmore (whether a resident or not) and some Swarthmore residents working elsewhere.

Borough Council is proposing to partially substitute the EIT for the property tax. In practice this means lower taxes for Swarthmore residents on average and higher taxes for non-residents who work in Swarthmore. The property tax in Swarthmore is basically a tax on households. The median household income in Swarthmore (where taxes will go down) is $152,360, while the median household income in Delaware County (where taxes will go up) is $89,546. You don’t have to be an economist to realize that such a change is regressive, and this is independent of the exemption of unearned income. 

Borough Council has commissioned two studies on the effect of the EIT: Keystone Collections Group (2025) and Keystone Municipal Solutions (2026). These studies agree on the total that could be collected with a 1% tax, $3 million, but they disagree significantly on who will pay it. I have put the differences in the table below:

The 2025 study states that one-half of the revenue will come from non-resident workers which has the regressive implications discussed above. The 2026 study states that $1 million will come from Swarthmore residents who are currently paying the tax to other municipalities. This results from a provision in the law which states that, except for those working in Philadelphia or out of state, the home municipality of the worker has first claim on the EIT. Since Swarthmore currently has no EIT, Swarthmore residents working in Media, for example, pay the EIT to Media, but if Swarthmore instituted an equivalent tax, that money would come to Swarthmore with no additional tax burden to these workers. 

This is a very attractive feature if true. The problem is that it is unlikely to be true. First, the 2025 study estimated the number to be less than one-third that amount. Second, a map provided by Keystone Municipal listed the top ten municipalities where Swarthmore residents work. Once one includes the 9% of workers who work out of state, the map includes 67% of all Swarthmore resident workers. Of that 67%, only 3.9% work in municipalities where their EIT would be refunded to Swarthmore. Whatever the exact numbers, the fact that the two studies disagree so dramatically should give Borough Council pause before implementing the EIT.

Finally, there is a provision of the EIT that does improve its progressivity. The Borough can exempt workers who make less than $12,000. The problem is that this is a very hard cutoff: workers making $11,999 pay no tax, but workers making $12,001 pay the full amount. Separate from the question of regressivity is the issue of taxation without representation, which on our nation’s 250th birthday should get some consideration. According to the 2025 study, 50% of the tax revenue comes from non-Swarthmore residents who had no say in the implementation of the tax. In conclusion, the property tax is an imperfect tax, but the EIT is significantly worse. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Previous Story

New Coaches Lead Swarthmore Volleyball in a Strong Season Start

Next Story

Artist of the Week: Spencer Kennedy ’27 on Creating a Unique Concert Experience

Latest from Opinion

The Myth of the All-Powerful White Man

Arman Hanifpour '27 argues that American intervention should not simply be understood as one-sided domination but as a relationship in which the less powerful country nonetheless has a degree of agency.

The Victims of the Blue Tsunami

Ellie Dowek ’28 criticizes high-profile Democrats' abandonment of the transgender community during the 2026 midterms, arguing that sacrificing their rights for political gain is indefensible.
Previous Story

New Coaches Lead Swarthmore Volleyball in a Strong Season Start

Next Story

Artist of the Week: Spencer Kennedy ’27 on Creating a Unique Concert Experience

Don't Miss