The Myth of the All-Powerful White Man

November 19, 2026
Phoenix Photo/Renee Xu

We have certain expectations of billionaires. When someone has more money than they could ever reasonably spend, we tend to think they should use at least some of it to help others. We can disagree about how much they owe, or which causes deserve their attention. But the basic expectation is difficult to dismiss: having extraordinary resources creates some responsibility to use them for the common good.

Why should we expect anything less from a global superpower?

There is a reason people around the world follow American politics so closely. They know how the Electoral College works, can distinguish red states from blue states, and often follow American elections more closely than elections in their own countries. Sometimes, the outcome of an American election can affect their lives more directly than the outcome of their own. When the decisions of one country carry such consequences for the rest of the world, it is reasonable to expect that country to recognize the responsibilities that come with its power.

Still, in American politics, there is a growing tendency to treat almost any such involvement with suspicion. Across the anti-imperialist left and the isolationist right, the argument is that America has its own interests, a long history of imperialism, and a record of disastrous interventions. From there, it supposedly follows that when the U.S. acts abroad, it is almost inevitably imposing its will on someone else. Even when people in another country actively request American assistance, their preferences are often treated as secondary to the larger question of what America is trying to accomplish.

At a University of Michigan town hall in September, a student told Abdul El-Sayed, the now senator-elect of Michigan, that his family had suffered under Iran’s government and asked whether he stood against the Islamic Revolutionary Guard. But El-Sayed did not say it. Instead, he said he supports pro-democracy movements abroad, but warned that when the U.S. moves to take out a foreign government, the frustration behind it gets used to justify “corporate interests” with “a real stake in the natural resources of a particular country.” Maybe so. That worry has history behind it, and this op-ed doesn’t deny it. But notice what happened to the question. The student asked about the IRGC. El-Sayed, however, treated the question as if the only thing worth answering was what America might want out of it.

What gets lost in this argument is the agency of the people on the other side of American power. America acts and everyone else is acted upon. Even when people abroad make their own calculations, express their own preferences, or actively seek American involvement in their national politics, those choices are often explained away by the assumption that American power is so overwhelming that other societies have little meaningful say in their relationship with it.

In my conversations, I have noticed that this way of thinking has something to do with the reality of American power at home. In American history, relations between white Americans and minority groups have often been marked by stark imbalances of power, in which one group’s interests and position can be understood to come at the expense of another’s. This dynamic has obviously shaped how Americans regard domination and interpret unequal relationships. But that understanding of American power, shaped by entirely legitimate criticism of the country’s domestic history, should not be reflexively projected onto how populations globally interact with each other today. A smaller country can seek an alliance with a superpower without surrendering its own interests, just as a weaker population can welcome assistance from a more powerful country without becoming its subordinate. But when every unequal relationship is interpreted through the lens of domination, it becomes difficult to distinguish cooperation from coercion. Even the expressed preferences of the weaker party become suspect. They are treated not as independent political choices, but as evidence of the stronger party’s influence. Eventually, the imbalance itself becomes proof that the weaker party must be losing.

This is the myth of the all-powerful white man: a domestic dynamic of racial domination scaled up into global omnipotence. It goes beyond recognizing that America is powerful. It treats American power as so total that other people cannot meaningfully choose how to engage with it. When people abroad seek American assistance, are they making a political choice, or have they simply been manipulated? When they welcome American cooperation, they are cast as collaborators in their own group’s subordination. This view also misunderstands their interests. American interests and the interests of foreign populations are not always opposed. The U.S. can pursue its own strategic interests and still do something that benefits someone else. Countries can have overlapping interests. People can welcome American assistance for reasons of their own. That does not make them naive, manipulated, or incapable of understanding the implications of American intervention.

Look at South Korea and Japan. Successive governments in both countries have maintained close security relationships with the U.S. because they see them as serving their own interests. Or consider Bosnia and Kosovo, where many people facing mass violence and ethnic cleansing welcomed American and NATO intervention as a means of protection. These are very different circumstances, but they prove the same point: American involvement is not always something imposed on people against their wishes. Sometimes it is something they actively seek.

Vietnam shows us the other side. The U.S. had an enormous military advantage, yet it could not force Northern Vietnamese forces to accept the political outcome it wanted. American power, though formidable, was not omnipotent. The same limits were apparent in Afghanistan and Iraq. In these cases, American military intervention could remove governments, but it could not manufacture lasting political legitimacy or guarantee local support for the political order that followed. In Afghanistan, the government that the U.S. had spent years supporting collapsed soon after U.S. forces withdrew. These failures showed how little American military power could accomplish when locals did not support or lend their cooperation to the project.

There is a strange paternalism in claiming to defend people from American domination while dismissing their own choices whenever those choices involve America. It is no less condescending to assume that people abroad cannot recognize their own interests than it is to assume that America can impose its will wherever it goes. Sometimes they resist American involvement. Sometimes they welcome it. Sometimes their interests align with America’s, and sometimes they do not.

The United States has enormous power, and that power carries enormous responsibilities. But the rest of the world is not simply at the mercy of the U.S. The people who live with the consequences of American foreign policy have their own interests, their own judgments, and their own capacity to shape what happens to them.

In trying to challenge the power of the white man, this worldview can end up granting him even more power than he actually possesses.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Previous Story

Photos, Coast to Coast

Next Story

Athlete of the Week: Josie Sarno ’30

Latest from Opinion

The Victims of the Blue Tsunami

Ellie Dowek ’28 criticizes high-profile Democrats' abandonment of the transgender community during the 2026 midterms, arguing that sacrificing their rights for political gain is indefensible.
Previous Story

Photos, Coast to Coast

Next Story

Athlete of the Week: Josie Sarno ’30

Don't Miss