Garment of Destiny: One Inmate, No Vote 

November 19, 2026
Photo/ACLU of Kansas

The squeak of the sneakers on the gymnasium floor sang a symphony of weariness as my inside classmates approached “the circle;” the space we share every Thursday. Their somber melody clashed with our own peppy steps, which staccato’d until they arrived at the center of the room. It was two days after the midterm elections, and many Swarthmore students were invigorated by the blue wave that had swept through the nation (though not without critique, as my close friend Ellie Dowek reminded us last week). Our classmates in the Philadelphia Industrial Correctional Center (PICC), however, were weighed down by the injustice of not having been given the opportunity to vote, despite this being their right in Pennsylvania. 

“I wanted to vote,” shared my classmate Fee, frustrated. “I vote every time. I want to make my voice heard.” 

In the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, people who are currently within a penal institution have the right to vote if they are pretrial detainees or convicted misdemeanants. In fact, people serving a misdemeanor sentence can vote in most states. However, having the right to vote and being able to exercise it are two different things. The main difference boils down to how much you are valued by — or seen as “belonging” to — the society that holds governmental institutions accountable. 

On Tuesday, Nov. 4, the women in PICC were reminded of what the pale white walls that enclose them scream at them every day: you are not a person to us anymore. Those responsible for ensuring that the women at PICC were given the technology allotted to them by the government to vote knew that their failure to do so would go unpunished and widely unnoticed. That beckons the question: when the motto “one person, one vote” is systemically undermined, can we truly say that we have a representative democracy?

The problem extends beyond the failure to uphold voting rights for people currently within the penal system. It is estimated that over 4.6 million Americans cannot vote due to a felony conviction. Of these, over 961,000 or around 20%, reside in my home state of Florida. It is joined by 24 other states in its restriction of voting rights due to past convictions, with the most prohibiting legislation, up to permanent disenfranchisement, mainly found in the Midwest and the South.

Not only do voting rights restrictions betray our country’s democratic values, but the effects of it disproportionately harm Black communities. One out of every nineteen voting-eligible Black Americans is disenfranchised due to a felony conviction. Keep in mind, only half of the states place limitations on felons’ voting rights, making it so that disenfranchised Black Americans are concentrated in areas that have a history of violence against Black people who try to exercise their right to vote. Incarceration, therefore, can be weaponized as an alternative, “legitimate,” way to systemically silence Black voices. Florida has an incarcerated prison population that is 48% Black and a jail population that is 41% Black, despite Black Florida residents making up 15% of the population.

The right to vote is vital to American democracy. In a system where individuals’ voices are heard through their representatives and where the state is responsible for providing the infrastructure that enables people to vote, barriers to voting give the state the power to silence whomever they choose. When civil rights are conditional, the law can be bent to deny them on a partisan and bigoted basis. As members of the Swarthmore community, it’s important for us to be aware that some members of our community, like Fee, are being refused access to voting. In turn, we can begin to advocate for the legislation that ensures that everyone’s voting rights are upheld and protected.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Previous Story

Borough Adds New Tax for Swarthmore Workers and Residents

Next Story

Photos, Coast to Coast

Latest from Opinion

The Myth of the All-Powerful White Man

Arman Hanifpour '27 argues that American intervention should not simply be understood as one-sided domination but as a relationship in which the less powerful country nonetheless has a degree of agency.

The Victims of the Blue Tsunami

Ellie Dowek ’28 criticizes high-profile Democrats' abandonment of the transgender community during the 2026 midterms, arguing that sacrificing their rights for political gain is indefensible.
Previous Story

Borough Adds New Tax for Swarthmore Workers and Residents

Next Story

Photos, Coast to Coast

Don't Miss