“Define Your Terms:” in this case, “Divestment”

December 4, 2014

To the Editor:

Our experience at Swarthmore five decades ago imprinted on us the value and importance of the first three words above.

We wonder if there are some significant differences in what parties in the discussion really mean by the term “divestment.”

Sample advertisement

The title of Board of Managers Chair Gil Kemp’s “empty gesture” op-ed on 20 November in the Phoenix is indeed accurate if the only action the college takes is to sell shares.  No one would know or notice.  Nothing accomplished.  This is the meaning of “divestment” used by money managers.  No additional purposes.

Gil’s op-ed title is not accurate, however, if the act and purpose of selling are publicly announced to the general and financial press, and perhaps even to board chairs at other schools and in their newspapers.  A public request from Gil to meet personally with the chair of the coal, tar sands, or other polluting company, with further publicity about the company’s (negative) reply, etc., would make the college’s leadership action even more meaningful.

The effects of such steps are hard to measure, but we believe something valuable is achieved.

The Rockefeller Brothers Fund is unloading significant fossil-fuel holdings and has become a very positive model — substantive action WITH significant, well-deserved publicity.

Swarthmore could do the same.

Edith Eddy ’64 and Jeb Eddy ’63

Palo Alto, CA

1 Comment Leave a Reply

  1. I concur. However, there can be more. Divestment will usually be followed by reinvestment of the proceeds of selling. In divesting of fossil fuels the college–or any organization or individual–may reinvest in renewable energy production companies, primarily solar and wind.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Previous Story

Why denouncing baseball’s steroid era is a mistake

Next Story

Kakkar competes in NCAA championships

Latest from Opinion

Letter from 129 Alumni Boycotting Reunion

We are writing as alumni/ae from the classes scheduled to hold their reunions in 2025 who have been saddened and outraged as we have watched Swarthmore abandon its principles over the last year and a half. We have watched as students protesting

Weekly Column: Swat Says

Did you do anything fun for Easter? Adrian Ferguson ’26: No. Homework. Ian Flynn ’28: I went on a nice, long walk in the woods. Jonah Sah ’27: I visited the house of one of my friends. His family is quite Jewish,

William Jin Platform

My name is William Jin, and I am running for SGO Senate at-large. I am running not just as an individual, but as a MOVEMENT. A movement to democratize Swarthmore by ENDING the two-party DUOPOLY that has a stranglehold on campus. For
Photo Courtesy of James Shelton

Rethinking the Origins of COVID and Pandemics to Come

In the summer of 2021, when I was still a ritualistic viewer of Stephen Colbert’s “The Late Show,” I remember a particularly striking conversation Colbert had with Jon Stewart about COVID. Stewart had been relatively removed from the public spotlight for several
Previous Story

Why denouncing baseball’s steroid era is a mistake

Next Story

Kakkar competes in NCAA championships

The Phoenix

Don't Miss