Krall Examines the Ethics of Experimental Medicine

November 18, 2007

Editor’s note: This article was initially published in The Daily Gazette, Swarthmore’s online, daily newspaper founded in Fall 1996. As of Fall 2018, the DG has merged with The Phoenix. See the about page to read more about the DG.

Ron Krall, a senior vice president in worldwide development at GlaxoSmithKline, spoke Friday about pharmaceutical ethics, particularly giving patients access to experimental medication outside of clinical trials. Krall, who was a math major in the class of 1969, did not use a traditional lecture format; instead, he led a discussion, even putting his personal email up on the board for “those of you who aren’t satisfied” by the necessarily brief discussion.

The lecture was based on a case study, in which a father requests an experimental medication for his 21-year-old daughter Amanda, who has terminal head-and-neck cancer. The medicine is currently in testing for lung cancer treatments; it seems likely, however, that it would work well for head-and-neck cancer. The drug works by suppressing epidermal growth factor receptors (EGFRs), which present in both lung cancer and head-and-neck cancer.

It would seem only natural to give Amanda the drug: if it did something bad to her, so what? She was going to die soon anyway. Indeed, when polled before the discussion most of the students were relatively sure that Amanda should be given the drug. On the other hand, if something bad did happen, then it would almost certainly interfere with the approval process for the drug, which — if all goes well — would otherwise be available to regular patients within about three years.

Even if the treatment works well, though, word will spread about how this medicine helped Amanda; other patients will demand it as well, and how could the company justify giving the drug to some patients but not others? Furthermore, giving the drug to Amanda would undermine the company’s ability to perform clinical trials for treating head-and-neck cancer. Clinical trials, to be meaningful, require a control group, but who would be willing to have a fifty-fifty chance of getting medication when they know that other patients were just given the drug?

In the end, the actual doctor decided not to give Amanda the medication. As Krall said, “We want medicines with benefits greater than harms, and we want those decisions to be based on evidence.” Unfortunately, in order to reach that goal, “we often have to be in a very unsatisfying place.”

Previous Story

Sports Update 11/17

Next Story

Gregory Frost Reads from Shadow Bridge

Latest from Sports

New Coaches Lead Swarthmore Volleyball in a Strong Season Start

After Harleigh Chwastyk took the opening as Swarthmore’s Interim Athletic Director in June 2026, two new coaches were hired to head the Swarthmore volleyball program this season. Despite the quick turnaround, they have led the team to its strongest start since 2017,

Athlete of the Week: Josie Sarno ’30

Goalkeeper Josie Sarno ’30 is a first-year sensation for Swarthmore’s field hockey this fall. Since arriving at Swarthmore for preseason, the first-year immediately stepped into a major defensive role, starting every game for the Garnet and notching eight clean sheets. Her success

The Inaugural Season of the Women’s Professional Baseball League

On Aug. 1, 99-year-old Maybelle Blair tossed the ceremonial first pitch to kick off the 2026 inaugural season of the Women’s Professional Baseball League (WPBL). A former professional player herself, Maybelle Blair pitched for the Peoria Redwings in the All-American Girls Baseball

Athlete of the Week: Dylan Myrick ’30

First-year Dylan Myrick is a freestyle, Individual Medley (IM), and breaststroke specialist for the Swarthmore men’s swim team. The Eugene, OR resident swam at his first collegiate meet on Oct. 24, where Swarthmore, Franklin & Marshall College, Ursinus College, and Dickinson College

Fueling the Phoenix: Newly Extended Dining Hall Hours

For much of Swarthmore’s history, students faced the reality of Sharples’ abbreviated hours: if you didn’t make it by the 8 p.m. closing time, you were going into the night without dinner. Student athletes would oftentimes be forced into rushing to the
Previous Story

Sports Update 11/17

Next Story

Gregory Frost Reads from Shadow Bridge

Don't Miss