Gerald Graff speaks on educational methods and sources

February 11, 2005

Editor’s note: This article was initially published in The Daily Gazette, Swarthmore’s online, daily newspaper founded in Fall 1996. As of Fall 2018, the DG has merged with The Phoenix. See the about page to read more about the DG.

Yesterday, Gerald Graff gave a lecture entitled “Keeping the Disciplines a Secret,” part of the Mellon Tri-College Symposium on the Teaching of Writing. Graff argued that undergraduate education frequently shortchanges students by not emphasizing the study of critical discourse in favor of “making statements in a vacuum.” He spoke to a diverse audience of Swarthmore and Tri-Co students and professors.

Graff, the author of “Beyond the Culture Wars,” and “Clueless in Academe,” is a professor at the University of Illinois at Chicago. He began by commenting on what he called the “best student obsession” of admissions offices, when admissions departments seek out those who are “already insiders to the academic club,” and that the US has always given “lip service to democratic education…I don’t think our society has ever really believed it was possible or desirable.”

Sample advertisement

He then moved on to his main thesis: that undergraduate education keeps students away from “the disciplines,” meaning the accumulated collection of scholarly thought on a discipline of knowledge. Undergraduate education, Graff said, exposes students to the subject matter itself but not to the study of the subject matter. This approach made sense in the beginning of the 20th century, when scholarship was dominated by positivism, he said, but is silly in what he sees as the current robust intellectual environment.

Graff’s example was a thesis for a poetry paper, which operated entirely on close reading of a poem rather than considering the body of scholarly interpretations of the poem. “It implies that the argument is not directed to anyone…such a way of thinking conceives the thesis as pointless,” he said, and emphasized that students’ papers should be conversational responses to other scholars.

His suggestions for improvement were that students should engage more fully in the critical tradition surrounding their subjects rather than just the sources themselves. “Otherwise, your teachers are letting you down,” he said. The talk was followed by a lively question and answer session where professors Jeffrey Murer of Political Science and Tim Burke of History, and several students, questioned Graff’s argument. When they take this approach, “students imitate a certain amorphous, ungrounded meta-method,” Burke said. “We should create a culture of debate,” Graff finished.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Previous Story

Panel shares true stories of homelessness

Next Story

Weekend roundup

Latest from News

Swarthmore Leaders React as SEPTA Announces Severe Cuts

On April 10, the South-Eastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority (SEPTA) announced widespread service cuts and fare increases for the 2026 fiscal year. The cuts, which total a 45% reduction of service, are the culmination of several years of long-term deficits that have only

New NCAA Policy Implications for Transgender Student-Athletes

Under a new NCAA policy banning transgender and gender non-conforming athletes from participating in women’s sports, the status of potential Swarthmore student-athletes is in question. The policy, enacted Feb. 6, places no restrictions on who can participate in men’s teams, but bans

Resident Peer Leader Hiring Cycle Sees Surge in Applications

As the spring semester comes to a close, many students and administrators are well into preparations for the 2025-2026 school year. The housing lottery has finished, students have completed pre-registration for classes, and many open campus jobs, including Resident Peer Leaders (RPLs),

Dr. Wade Manora Jr. Takes on IC Role

In January 2024, the Intercultural Center (IC) announced a change in leadership for the first time since 2019. Dr. Wade Manora Jr. is the new Assistant Dean and Director of the IC, succeeding Dr. Imaani El-Burki in the role. Manora was the
Previous Story

Panel shares true stories of homelessness

Next Story

Weekend roundup

The Phoenix

Don't Miss