Student Council overturns SAC decision on debate broadcast funding

September 30, 2004

Editor’s note: This article was initially published in The Daily Gazette, Swarthmore’s online, daily newspaper founded in Fall 1996. As of Fall 2018, the DG has merged with The Phoenix. See the about page to read more about the DG.

In a marathon meeting that stretched from Tuesday night well into Wednesday, Student Council (SC) voted to take the rare action of disagreeing with a Social Affairs Committee (SAC) decision on the funding of a campus event, choosing to grant the Swarthmore Voter Registration Coalition (SVRC) $150 for an event that will include the screening of the presidential debates on Thursday night. The decision was the culmination of over two hours of sometimes heated and sometimes philosophical debate about SAC, Student Council, and their roles in representing the student body.

The process for funding began with a typical proposal to SAC for funding. Ethan Ucker ’07, one of the heads of SVRC, requested $350 at SAC’s Monday evening meeting–a quantity of funding which Ucker said he was told was consistent with that for a large weekend party. SAC rejected the proposal on the basis that it fell under the category of “events which advance political ideologies.” Ucker expressed to Student Council that he felt that the event was not promoting a political ideology but rather was “a chance to forego partisanship,” and thus was requesting that Student Council provide funding for the event. He noted the value of SAC funding for an event, saying that it increases campus awareness of the event and serves as an endorsement by the student body.

Student Council representative and ex officio SAC member Myra Kate Vallianos explained SAC’s decision to SC, saying that “although it doesn’t promote an ideology…it is promoting political ideologies–that’s what debates do.” She added that the vote was “surprisingly close.”

Student Council members, with SAC Co-Directors Darshan Patel ’05 and Charlie Sussman ’05 present for reference at various times, set about the task of debating the correctness of SAC’s decision. With Vallianos abstaining, the other ten members of SC quickly decided that SAC had incorrectly interpreted its bylaw and that the SVRC event should have received funding.

The decision on the proper course of action to rectify the error was much tougher, and heated debate ensued between those who wanted simply to send a message by funding a minimal amount for the party and those who felt that SVRC deserved to get all $350 it initially requested. Complicating the matter were the fact that SVRC had been offered funding by the President’s Office should SAC refuse to pay for it and that SAC had already granted its weekly suggest amount of funding.

Student Council attempted to balance all of these concerns, including the dominating theme that SC and SAC are ultimately organizations that work for the good of students. Jon Fombonne ’05 expressed this view, noting that “SAC is supposed to represent, in its decisions, what the student body wants to spend money on.” Sussman explained that even if SAC had agreed to fund the party on a philosophical basis, it would likely not have given SVRC all $350.

While Student Council strongly considered granting SVRC all $350, an 8-2 vote (Vallianos abstaining) ultimately granted Ucker and his group $150, with the understanding that the rest would be provided by the President’s Office.

Such a debate on SAC’s interpretation of its bylaws has long been anticipated. Last spring a similar question arose when the College Democrats requested funding for an all-campus study break. Student Council may further consider revising the bylaws to make them more explicit on this issue, especially since this decision may set a precedent for the funding of other nonpartisan political events.

Asked his reaction to the decision, Ucker said: “I think it was important that the organizations that represent the student body get on board with this in more than a symbolic way without taking away funding from other events.”

Previous Story

SAC issues statement on “Professors and School Girls” party at DU

Next Story

Student Council announces tentative plan for naming New Dorm

Latest from Sports

New Coaches Lead Swarthmore Volleyball in a Strong Season Start

After Harleigh Chwastyk took the opening as Swarthmore’s Interim Athletic Director in June 2026, two new coaches were hired to head the Swarthmore volleyball program this season. Despite the quick turnaround, they have led the team to its strongest start since 2017,

Athlete of the Week: Josie Sarno ’30

Goalkeeper Josie Sarno ’30 is a first-year sensation for Swarthmore’s field hockey this fall. Since arriving at Swarthmore for preseason, the first-year immediately stepped into a major defensive role, starting every game for the Garnet and notching eight clean sheets. Her success

The Inaugural Season of the Women’s Professional Baseball League

On Aug. 1, 99-year-old Maybelle Blair tossed the ceremonial first pitch to kick off the 2026 inaugural season of the Women’s Professional Baseball League (WPBL). A former professional player herself, Maybelle Blair pitched for the Peoria Redwings in the All-American Girls Baseball

Athlete of the Week: Dylan Myrick ’30

First-year Dylan Myrick is a freestyle, Individual Medley (IM), and breaststroke specialist for the Swarthmore men’s swim team. The Eugene, OR resident swam at his first collegiate meet on Oct. 24, where Swarthmore, Franklin & Marshall College, Ursinus College, and Dickinson College

Fueling the Phoenix: Newly Extended Dining Hall Hours

For much of Swarthmore’s history, students faced the reality of Sharples’ abbreviated hours: if you didn’t make it by the 8 p.m. closing time, you were going into the night without dinner. Student athletes would oftentimes be forced into rushing to the
Previous Story

SAC issues statement on “Professors and School Girls” party at DU

Next Story

Student Council announces tentative plan for naming New Dorm

Don't Miss