On Nov. 12, the Aydelotte Foundation hosted an event in its “Just Tech” faculty and staff seminar series on the newly published book, Against Tech Oligarchy, featuring authors Clarissa Redwine and J.S. Tan. The talk was moderated by Linda Huber, the Foundation’s postdoctoral fellow in social justice & technology.
Huber began the lecture by establishing the book’s relevance to the Swarthmore community. She cited the growth of computational technologies across professions: at the college, “more than 25% of Swarthmore graduates” major in engineering and computer science and pursue related career paths.
She argued that these realities reflect the need for “a critical interventionist stance towards the tech industry,” which she hopes will impact the next generation of tech workers writ large and Swarthmore students in particular. Huber suggested that audience members take note of the ways in which “some of these insights translate to the way that we organize and govern ourselves here on this campus.”
Redwine and Tan’s Industry Experience
Huber’s first question invited Redwine and Tan to share their respective experiences of working and organizing within the technology industry. Redwine began in Accelerator Ventures, a venture capital program for startup investments, where she said she noticed “pretty extreme forms of exploitation.” She later moved to a role at Kickstarter, a “public benefit corporation” that primarily aims to fund creative projects.
The company was “almost the exact opposite of [Accelerator Ventures],” Redwine said, stressing its community and project-based operation. While working at Kickstarter, she witnessed an incident in which the company’s management decided to censor a project on the platform “because of pressure from the alt-right,” which was against the company’s stated mission. Redwine’s coworkers took collective action to push back against this decision, a moment that she described as “a transformative experience.”
Tan entered the industry in the 2010s, and began labor organizing around 2017. At the time, the concept of organizing in the tech industry was unfamiliar to the general public. It appeared almost self-contradictory, according to Tan, as employees in the tech sector usually receive high salaries, countering the traditional blue-collar image associated with “labor” and unionization.
“It was kind of a conversation on what is the class position for the tech workers,” Tan recounted. Then, in 2018, a turning point occurred as a wave of Microsoft employees raged in protests against the company’s contract with ICE.
A year later, Amazon workers went on strike for climate justice, demanding that the company terminate its collaboration with oil and gas centers. At the time, Tan was sent by Microsoft to work in Kazakhstan for the company’s collaboration with Chevron, a major oil and gas corporation. As a close observer of the industry, Tan came to realize the power that tech workers could amalgamate collectively.
Impetus for Writing Against Tech Oligarchy
Turning to the book, Huber inquired about the authors’ impetus for writing. In response, Tan traced the evolution of what they referred to as the “Tech Worker Movement.”
The movement’s first phase spiked in 2018 with the series of events described above. The transition into the second phase of the movement was marked by the successful unionization efforts of Kickstarter employees, in which Redwine participated. At this stage, tech workers sought affiliations with international unions, such as the Office & Professional Employees International Union (OPEIU) and the United Steelworkers, so as to “grow their strength by developing structural power.”
Despite the intensification of these efforts, they proved largely ineffective. “We were seeing a lot of these campaigns dissipate as we pushed the strategy harder and harder,” Tan recounted.
In October of 2022, Elon Musk completed a $44 billion deal to purchase the social media platform Twitter (which he subsequently renamed X). On Nov. 3, 2022, the New York Times reported that Musk had initiated a 7,500-employee layoff in the company.
“This left us speechless,” Redwine commented. As she recalled, the 2021 ban on President Trump’s account following the Jan. 6 attacks was a win realized by Twitter employees’ collective pressure. Under Musk, however, a “majority strike” to protect the laid-off employees failed. After discussing the series of tech union losses at length, Tan and Redwine agreed to compile their reflections in a book.
Redwine and Tan Organize
At this point in the talk, Huber invited Redwine and Tan to describe what their organizing efforts looked like to better contextualize the discussion. Redwine began with her campaign at Kickstarter.
While working at the company, she moved towards unionization as a way to create pressure on Kickstarter. This strategy was an alternative to placing external pressure on the company because the organizers and workers “did not want to tarnish the brand of the company which was very important [to them].”
She described the process of unionization: a card and petition-signing campaign can create a workplace supermajority of committed members, which is followed by an attempt to gain legal recognition under the National Labour Relations Act. Unionization is a strategy adopted by the majority of tech worker labor organizers. Beyond this technical explanation of union organizing, Redwine said she’d offer a new definition of a union as, “any two or more workers that are coming together to fight for better working conditions from the boss.”
Two critiques Redwine put forth for this recognition strategy are its slow speed, and its “somewhat theoretical and abstract” nature. To the second point, she argued that the high number of necessary conversations “delays the moments of class conflict that spurred the tech worker movement in the first place.” In the long-haul process to build up recognition, she said, “we lost those moments of clashes” that give birth to “class consciousness.”
Tan went on to point out that in the transition from the movement’s first phase to its second phase, the second phase primarily aimed to provide workers with protection while upholding worker leverage.
“Tech work is quite literally about automating for your bosses,” said Tan. The labor process of tech workers themselves presents a particularity in regards to traditional theory of change. A strike should, traditionally and theoretically, pose a great threat to the employers by halting production. The same is not seen in the tech industry, Tan observed, citing Musk’s Twitter layoff, in which the company was able to keep running.
The Impact of Artificial Intelligence on the Technology Sector
Before opening the floor to audience questions, Huber asked about one of the most relevant topics both in and outside of the tech sector today — AI, and its particular influence on worker organizing in the industry.
Redwine told a story about workers at Meta. The company announced, without workers’ consent, that it will collect and use employees’ data (e.g. mouse clicks, screen-recordings, keystrokes) to “train an AI model that could do [their] daily work.” Workers organized as a result. Organizers found that the “choke point” was in organizing the workers responsible for training the AI models, the same employees who were the “biggest leverage” in this context. Management eventually paused the program as a result of pressure from organizers.
With regard to the broader working environment, Tan noticed tech companies’ use of AI to boost efficiency, as competitions are being incited among workers to use more AI. At the same time, speed-ups and layoffs are taking place across big companies as a result of advancements in the AI sector.
Questions from the Audience
An audience member inquired about Redwine’s experience at Accelerator Ventures, her vision for potential changes to the venture capital industry, and what worker organizing in the startup environment looks like.
Redwine described employees at Accelerator Ventures being overworked, as well as a culture of “hyper-competition between founders.” She noted that she doesn’t see the venture capital sector becoming more progressive; as for the startup environment, while startups are usually gathered around a shared mission without “the need to generate profit for a while,” she explained that later injections of capital could have them become more “volatile,” thereby “great catalysts for organizing.”
Another member of the crowd drew attention to workers’ demands in the tech sector, which often deviated from “material concerns” that unions usually fight for, and questioned the necessity of the union for tech workers. An additional audience member built on this question, asking whether there are aspects and leverages that tech worker organizers can learn from traditional unions.
“The reason that people are so focused on … worker organizing, in the forms of unions, is [that] there is leverage to be grasped,” Redwine responded. Such leverage could be particular to every workplace, not strictly adhering to a standardized recognition playbook.
Tan added that in earlier years, employees entering the industry “had incredible individual labor market power.” With tech’s growing prevalence in all socioeconomic sectors, tech workers have come to realize their industry should be “broadly accountable,” spurring earlier workers’ actions centered around contentious social justice topics.
Finally, Huber closed the discussion by inviting the authors to expand on forms of union alternative to the traditionally recognized form, such as the Alphabet Workers Union (AWU). Redwine stressed the idea that class consciousness emerges from collective struggles: “That is what spurred [our] interest in unions to begin with, to build more sustained worker power and class consciousness.”
