Swarthmore has provided its faculty with home purchasing assistance for decades. However, faculty who choose to opt into this program are restricted to a specific geographical area. In the past ten years, that region has gradually grown, affecting where faculty tend to reside and, as a result, the extent to which they are involved in campus life.
Currently, full time faculty with at least three years remaining on their appointment, as well as all part-time faculty, are able to opt into the College Home Purchase Assistance program. The program offers eligible faculty “the opportunity for a ten-year forgivable home purchase assistance loan — 10% of the property’s purchase price, up to $57,500.” The college provides faculty members with this loan, and if faculty members stay in their homes for at least ten years, then the loan is completely forgiven.
In order to benefit from the program, faculty must purchase a home “within the Wallingford-Swarthmore School District or within five miles from any SEPTA Regional Rail station along the Media-Elwyn line, including center city Philadelphia, or within five miles of the Frankford Transfer Station line.”
These guidelines mark a significant expansion of the range of residential locations available to faculty members seeking housing assistance. According to an old version of the faculty housing webpage in 2015, faculty could receive mortgage assistance “for homes which are within one and one-half miles of Parrish Hall or in Chester City or Media Borough.”
The monetary benefits of this program were more generous, providing a “20, 25, 30 or 40-year monthly amortizing first mortgage loans of up to 100% of the College appraised value” and being “subject to a cap based on the average sale price of homes in Swarthmore over the prior three years.” However, the program was only available to tenured or other full-time faculty members. In other words, the college would provide employer-backed mortgage offerings to faculty members, lessening the down payment obligation and providing different rates and conditions than a bank might.
History of the Home Purchase Assistance Program
Between 2015 and 2022, the housing assistance program boundaries began to grow. In 2018, the college extended the range to include any home within the Wallingford-Swarthmore School District, or within 1.5 miles from any SEPTA Regional Rail station along the Media-Elwyn line (now Media-Wawa). In 2022, the boundaries changed to the current allowance.
In an email correspondence with The Phoenix, Vice President for Finance and Administration Rob Goldberg explained that the college reviews its mortgage assistance program to “make sure it stays relevant to the needs of our faculty.” He notes two reasons for the program’s expansion: increased housing prices in the area directly surrounding campus and the faculty’s increased interest in living closer to Philadelphia.
“The mortgage assistance program is meant to help faculty purchase a home near Swarthmore but we recognized that changes in the housing market meant that faculty were looking at houses in neighboring areas that were more affordable. We adjusted our program accordingly, and we are always analyzing the local housing market and are open to making future adjustments if needed,” Goldberg wrote.
Swarthmore borough housing prices have been rising for decades. A recent borough-commissioned report found that home values rose about 20% over inflation levels between 2000 and 2020 and jumped another 20% over inflation levels between 2020 and 2022.
The Faculty Recommend a Change
Henry C. and Charlotte Turner Professor and Section Head of German Studies Sunka Simon served as Associate Provost for Faculty Development between 2014 and 2018. In that position, she chaired the faculty committee for diversity and excellence and surveyed the faculty for topics the committee should address. One of the stand-out selections was housing: faculty were having trouble finding affordable residences when restricted to a 1.5 mile radius around Parrish Hall.
For the committee, this presented an equity issue — most faculty members would not be able to afford a home in the area, and thus benefit from the mortgage assistance program, without an additional massive loan. Simon reflected, “we [the committee] thought, this is one thing that doesn’t seem to be promoting the college’s mission for equity, inclusivity, and diversity.”
Additionally, the college’s position in the suburbs seemed to be driving certain faculty away from Swarthmore in favor of living in Philadelphia. After looking through past faculty meeting minutes, the faculty committee found that projected faculty diversity benchmarks set in the 1990s were not being met — the committee suspected that changing the housing benefit to encompass a broader area, especially Philadelphia, could contribute positively to Swarthmore’s attractiveness and retention rates for LGBTQ+ faculty and faculty of color.
Simon and the committee conducted an outreach effort, communicating with peer institutions about how they approach faculty housing benefits. One of the main findings was that including a city within the boundaries would “make people feel like they have a choice in where they are going to live and might [make faculty] feel more comfortable in communities other than those in suburbia or in rural areas.”
As a result, the committee proposed an expansion of the mortgage policy to include the regional rail line. At the same time, the college began to position itself more broadly as integrating Philadelphia, with some coursework like the Tri-Co Philly program, which offers courses taught in and centered around the city, beginning to develop.
According to Vice President of Communications and Marketing Andy Hirsch, then-Provost Tom Stevenson and then-Vice President for Finance and Administration Greg Brown formally established the faculty recommendation into college policy.
Benefits of the Expanded Boundaries
For faculty, the more flexible boundaries bring clear benefits. Associate Professor of Sociology Daniel Laurison lives in Philadelphia and is glad he was not restricted to any of the nearby suburbs.
“As a queer and trans person, it was important to me that my kids (and I) be in a place with queer and trans community, and while there are certainly some queer and trans people everywhere, there are more of us in bigger cities.”
Laurison also notes that the city has afforded his family many other benefits he wouldn’t find closer to campus, like the available schools, public transportation, and racial and class diversity across the communities. For him, “there is no (plausible) amount of financial incentive that would have gotten us to raise our kids in Swarthmore.”
Access to public transportation was a factor in the decision-making process for commuting faculty as well. Goldberg explained the decision supports the school’s sustainability goals because it encourages faculty to take the regional rail into work rather than driving.
Professor of Economics Syon Bhanot pointed out that attending to faculty desires to live in the city may also help with recruiting from a wider pool of qualified candidates. He added that the “salaries the college offers are not always competitive with peers (research universities in particular), though this isn’t true in every department.”
“So by having more generous housing related policies, the college can more easily recruit quality people to join the faculty at the offered salaries.”
Shifting Culture on Campus
At the same time, Bhanot also acknowledged a drawback: the effects of reduced faculty presence on the campus culture. He noted the result “need not necessarily be bad, but certainly some people pine for the ‘old days’ when there was a bit more of a small-town campus presence amongst faculty.”
While Bhanot mentioned that there is some disagreement among faculty as to whether these changes have harmed campus life, he reflected that the previous model created “more of a culture of faculty presence — that means having classes in your house, being more present at campus events in the evening, etc.”
In contrast, the faculty is currently more spread out, which Bhanot notes “is somewhat natural but also somewhat a consequence of college policies.” Faculty now have the option to commute from afar to teach their classes or advise, not necessarily staying for longer than need be. “I think that’s caused some degree of friction and challenges for the college. I don’t think it’s all necessarily bad, but I think it just changed the culture of the place.”
Laurison agrees that a more geographically spread out faculty leads to fewer staff on campus for weekend or evening events. He speculates there are likely a small number of faculty who have been incentivized to live closer to campus with a stricter mortgage program. However, he contends, “I don’t think that trade-off is a good argument for reversing the expansion of the policy, but I get the concerns.”
Simon claims that the idea that faculty proximity to the college leads to increased engagement is a fallacy. She highlights that some faculty living in the surrounding areas come to campus less than some faculty commuting from Philadelphia or New York. Ultimately these decisions are not policy-related, but rather boil down to individual professors’ “personal preferences or priorities.”
While there has been a cultural shift where students and faculty might have previously had more regular interactions of a mixed academic and personal nature due to the seminar dinner traditions, Simon points out that the demographics at the college have also greatly changed. The predominantly male faculty of the past relied on their partners to organize and prepare for at-home meals during seminar dinners. A “shift in demographics, including working women” offered new and positive opportunities of student engagement, but it also brought about change.
However, Simon does note that some faculty members “don’t take it on themselves to be mentors,” a role that comes more easily with increased engagement and presence on campus. Specifically, she mentions the encouragement she felt when she was a junior faculty member to work in her office with the door open and be accessible to students outside of classes no longer pervades the faculty at large.
