Oftentimes we think of this dichotomy between living and dead — a person is either alive or they’re not, a language is either extant or extinct, a style is either “in” or “out,” and so on. But what about the dying? — I say this thinking of cable television, which in a generation or two might be a vestige of the past; or the South African language Nǁng, of which only one fluent speaker survives; or the sole pair of northern white rhinoceros, both of whom are female and therefore left without a mate. The species is functionally extinct, as there’s no hope of reproduction, and yet two are still alive, and healthy at that. So how do we define something on the precipice like this? Is it living or dead?
Noah Segan’s crime thriller “The Only Living Pickpocket in New York” (2026) seeks to answer this question. As its title might suggest, its protagonist Harry Lehman (John Turturro) gets by via a dying trade — pickpocketing. Modern New York — where swiped credit cards are easily cancelled, and security cameras capture everything — has all but exterminated the craft. Still, with the help of his reseller Ben (Steve Buscemi), Harry gets by.
Despite his unsympathetic profession, Harry’s motivation is proven to be noble — providing for his wife Rosie (Karina Arroyave), who’s catatonic and isn’t able to speak, let alone work. For this reason, it’s easier to find some sympathy for our hero, or at least humor in watching him coolly pluck phones and wallets from unsuspecting passersby. Like him, we’re lulled into a sense of security regarding his lifestyle, assuming that, as long as he keeps his head low, he’ll be able to keep it up for the foreseeable future.
Harry’s good spirits are soon dampened when he flies too close to the sun and purloins a bag belonging to Dylan (Will Price), the heir of an influential mafia family. The contents of this bag, and, specifically, one flash drive which Harry innocently chucks away, turn out to be very important, containing hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of cryptocurrency. Unsurprisingly, Dylan and his goons track down Harry and imply that, while he’s already as good as dead to them, they won’t kill his wife too so long as he finds and retrieves the flash drive.
Despite the obviously tense situation, the pacing of the film isn’t as frantic as you might think. Rather, the bulk of the movie reads as a tribute to the city and its sights, complete with a lively yet unhurried jazz score. Befitting a man of his age, Harry takes his sweet time with the quest, even taking detours like a meeting with his daughter Kelly (Tatiana Maslany). They haven’t spoken in decades, and it’s implied Harry’s only visiting because he believes himself to be in his final days.
Like his relationship with his daughter, Harry seems caught in a strange limbo as the film slowly unfolds — not quite alive, but not yet dead. Indeed, his actions are those of a man coming to terms with the fact that he’s about to die: a revelation he’s come to perhaps even before the audience does. This “forgone conclusion” doesn’t cheapen his character progression, though — the stress, plus the effects of the modern world, still take their significant toll. For one, his lack of a mobile phone means he has to resort to using a pay phone or, more commonly, borrowing someone else’s cell, which forestalls the live updates Dylan demands. Harry begins to grow deeply weary in very real, visible ways (though clearly his mind is no less sharp).
Near the end of the movie we’re treated to a truly surprising turn — another pickpocket, this one young and spry, and trying to swipe from Harry, no less. At first glance (and probably a more in-depth look too), this renders the title fully misleading. But there are several ways to take it: for example, we could assume that the title is Harry’s description of himself and, despite how world-wise he purports to be, he’s simply wrong. My favorite interpretation, which I alluded to earlier, is as follows: for most of this movie, Harry is marked for death and no longer a “living” creature. This would make the eponymous only living pickpocket the young protégé, though we only see a glimpse of him. (Or, of course, the film could just be lying to you.)
No matter the justification, the film makes it clear by its end that the humble art of pickpocketing, while perhaps dying, is not dead yet (for one, the American-centered movie doesn’t mention that it’s a bustling career in Europe’s tourist centers). Maybe the fault is in the word “dying,” which implies it’s a one-way trajectory, one careening from one end of the dichotomy to the other without any way to reverse it. But things we place in the gray space between life and death are often heading back towards life. (Scientists are working on embryo transfers for the northern white rhinoceros; the lone speaker of Nǁng, Katrina Esau, is actively leading a school to impart her language to the next generation.) Harry neglects that he has an active role in deciding which way he’s moving, towards life or towards death. He can choose his own future, and how he impacts others — what he can give instead of what he can take.
Among many other things, “The Only Living Pickpocket in New York” is a tribute to New York City, which I’ve never visited, perhaps severely hampering my enjoyment of the film; but I sincerely recommend that anyone invested in the city, or interested in pickpocketing, or pondering the liminal space between life and death, gives it a watch.
