College Defends Economic Accessibility Efforts

Editor’s note: This article was initially published in The Daily Gazette, Swarthmore’s online, daily newspaper founded in Fall 1996. As of Fall 2018, the DG has merged with The Phoenix. See the about page to read more about the DG.

As the college application season heats up, colleges across the country look to diversify their student populations both in terms of race and socio-economic status. On September 16, The New York Times released its 2015 College Access Index. The index measures top colleges’ efforts on economic diversity, taking into account the share of students who receive Pell grants, their graduation rates, and the prices that the colleges charge low and middle-income students.

Swarthmore ranks 56th on the accessibility list despite having the 6th largest endowment per student, raising concerns of whether the college is truly accessible to low-income students.

However, Swarthmore disputes the reliability of the index.

The data used by the New York Times is taken from federal sources that don’t fully take into account the full financial situation of students receiving financial aid from Swarthmore and many of its peer institutions,” Vice President of Finance Greg Brown wrote in an email.

The New York Times agreesthat the currently available statistics have limitation,” but also said that “if colleges released more detailed statistics — such as a breakdown of their student body into comparable income buckets — they would happily use them in their analysis.”

Swarthmore is able to offer need-based, loan-free financial aid awards to all qualified students because of the size of our endowment,” Brown wrote. “Based on the income distribution of aided students in the Class of 2019 (which is not part of the New York Times’s data set), I believe that we are succeeding in improving our access for low income students.”

While Swarthmore financial aid packages are loan-free, 33% of 2014 graduates took out loans at some point during their time at the college, graduating with an average debt of $21,866, according to Swarthmore’s 2014-2015 Common Data Set.

“Students choose to take out loans for a variety of personal reasons.  In many instances, particularly for families with higher incomes, a student loan may be used in lieu of using parental assets to meet the parents’ contribution to their child’s education,” Brown wrote. “While we do not require or encourage students to borrow, the option to take out low interest federal loans is available to all qualified students.”

Furthermore, Brown “anticipates that endowment spending on financial aid will grow, thereby increasing the spending rate in future years.”

Swarthmore’s rank on the index paints a negative image of the college in terms of accessibility, however, the college utilizes different avenues to reach out to low-income students.

One example is QuestBridge, an organization that connects low-income, high-achieving students to the nation’s top colleges. Swarthmore has been a partner school for QuestBridge for a few years and has participated in the College Match Program. This program awards a select few low-income students with an admission and a full scholarship to the college.

Our first year we brought in about nine students and this past year, [about] 8% of the Class of 2019 are QuestBridge participants,” wrote Vice President and Dean of Admissions Jim Bock in an email.

With the success of QuestBridge, Swarthmore has joined another group, the Coalition for Access, Affordability and Success, to expand on accessibility.

“The goal of the coalition is to broaden access to higher education for students who have struggled with financial aid and other elements of the application process and encourage more students to consider college,” said a press statement released by the coalition.

With this new application process, low-income students should have an easier time applying to the most selective colleges in the nation. This additional assistance is crucial to attract more low-income students to top colleges in general because low-income students lack the resources to provide them with information about the admissions and the financial aid process.

Aside from joining groups, Swarthmore has been doing additional work to reach out to low-income students. This year, the college is joining up with College Greenlight, a community based organization that partners with over 800 organizations nation-wide to connect traditionally underrepresented students to colleges. Additionally, the college created a new Director of Access position, and is offering two Discover Swarthmore programs, said Bock.

David Chan

David, some know him by his nickname DJ, is a sophomore from the Bay Area. He has plans to major in film and media studies and to minor in English Literature. He enjoys swimming and traveling to different places. Because fall is the season when new and returning TV shows premiere, he will spend a lot of his free time during fall semester watching all of his favorite shows, which include American Horror Story, Scream Queens, and How to Get Away with Murder.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

The Phoenix

Discover more from The Phoenix

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading