Swat students victorious in copyright lawsuit

October 4, 2004

Editor’s note: This article was initially published in The Daily Gazette, Swarthmore’s online, daily newspaper founded in Fall 1996. As of Fall 2018, the DG has merged with The Phoenix. See the about page to read more about the DG.

US District Court Judge Jeremy Fogel ruled largely in favor of Swarthmore students Nelson Pavlosky ’06 and Luke Smith ’06 last Thursday, finding that “[t]he fact that Diebold never actually brought suit against any alleged infringer suggests strongly that Diebold sought to use the [Digital Millennium Copyright Act’s] safe harbor provisions–which were designed to protect ISPs, not copyright holders–as a sword to suppress publication of embarrassing content rather than as a shield to protect its intellectual property.” While Fogel did not grant every request made by the plaintiffs, Pavlosky commented that “[t]he denied portions are not important either for the outcome of the case or for setting precedent…Our claim that Diebold interfered with our contract for Swarthmore for internet service was tenuous and not really important…[Fogel] said that the punishments under 512(f) [the relevant section of the DMCA] were sufficient to cover any of Diebold’s DMCA abuse. This is fine, since the ruling on the DMCA, a federal law, is more important and interesting than any ruling on California state law.” As a result of the case, a precedent has been set limiting the use of the copyright infringment provisions of the DMCA.

As previously reported in the Gazette, Pavlosky and Smith posted a series of internal Diebold memos that identify security flaws in the company’s widely used voting machines on the Swarthmore Coalition for the Digital Commons website last year. At the time the memos were available on a number of internet sites. It is not known for certain how the memos initially entered circulation, whether obtained by illegal means or leaked by an employee. In an attempt to suppress the circulation of the memos Diebold used copyright infringement provisions of the DMCA to get ISPs hosting the memos to shut down websites on which they were posted. The Electronic Frontier Foundation filed a lawsuit, on behalf of Pavlosky, Smith, and the Online Policy Group, another ISP hosting the memos, against Diebold for improper use of the copyright provisions of the DMCA. Diebold later withdrew their legal threats against the students, but Pavlosky and Smith continued in their lawsuit in order to ensure a ruling on the use of the DMCA provisions. With Thursday’s ruling, Pavlosky and Smith obtained their desired result.

Pavlosky sees the case as an “important precedent that puts some teeth into section 512(f) of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, which sets strong penalties for people [and] corporations who abuse the powers that the DMCA gives them.” While he still finds the content of the DMCA objectionable, Pavlosky noted that this precedent-setting decision makes it “a slightly more balanced and less oppressive law.”

Free Culture Swarthmore, the organization formerly known as the Swarthmore Coalition for the Digital Commons, will be hosting a victory party shortly after fall break. As to the meaning of the case for the future Pavlosky commented that it “demonstrates the ridiculous, oppressive lengths to which copyright has extended, and…the need for pro bono legal representation from organizations like the Electronic Frontier Foundation, which provided some of our lawyers,” adding “[t]hose who believe that this defense of our [First] Amendment rights was important, please donate to the EFF to make sure that our rights continue to be preserved in the future!”

Previous Story

Monday, October 4, 2004

Next Story

Swatties form fan club and host tailgate to increase “Tide Pride”

Latest from Sports

New Coaches Lead Swarthmore Volleyball in a Strong Season Start

After Harleigh Chwastyk took the opening as Swarthmore’s Interim Athletic Director in June 2026, two new coaches were hired to head the Swarthmore volleyball program this season. Despite the quick turnaround, they have led the team to its strongest start since 2017,

Athlete of the Week: Josie Sarno ’30

Goalkeeper Josie Sarno ’30 is a first-year sensation for Swarthmore’s field hockey this fall. Since arriving at Swarthmore for preseason, the first-year immediately stepped into a major defensive role, starting every game for the Garnet and notching eight clean sheets. Her success

The Inaugural Season of the Women’s Professional Baseball League

On Aug. 1, 99-year-old Maybelle Blair tossed the ceremonial first pitch to kick off the 2026 inaugural season of the Women’s Professional Baseball League (WPBL). A former professional player herself, Maybelle Blair pitched for the Peoria Redwings in the All-American Girls Baseball

Athlete of the Week: Dylan Myrick ’30

First-year Dylan Myrick is a freestyle, Individual Medley (IM), and breaststroke specialist for the Swarthmore men’s swim team. The Eugene, OR resident swam at his first collegiate meet on Oct. 24, where Swarthmore, Franklin & Marshall College, Ursinus College, and Dickinson College

Fueling the Phoenix: Newly Extended Dining Hall Hours

For much of Swarthmore’s history, students faced the reality of Sharples’ abbreviated hours: if you didn’t make it by the 8 p.m. closing time, you were going into the night without dinner. Student athletes would oftentimes be forced into rushing to the
Previous Story

Monday, October 4, 2004

Next Story

Swatties form fan club and host tailgate to increase “Tide Pride”

Don't Miss